 |
| Copied From Toeas.com |
Eileen, why the angry emoticon? Why the caption that tells me where you got it from? Why is this post in place of your weekly Tuney Tuesday meme?
To answer your questions, starting with the Tuney Tuesday question, I learned something just an hour ago, and I felt it deserved a special post. So, JB, I'm sorry I can't do my weekly Tuney Tuesday meme that I promise, but I really feel that this deserves a lot of attention and has to be posted as soon as possible. In fact, I'm staying up just to write this, because I honestly think it has to be addressed. By me, maybe not, but by somebody out there in the book blogosphere, yes. It's something that we, as book bloggers, should be mad about and it relates to plagiarism. So, from now on, I'm going to try my very best to cite where I get my summaries, lyrics, pictures, and all that somehow because I don't want what happened to someone else to happen to me.
I don't know if I have the right to say this, or even discuss it in a post, but I'm going to because I feel that you guys deserve to know. Trust me, I know what it feels like to now know anything, and I want my readers to know, because you all should.
What Exactly Happened?
A few months ago, away from the prying eyes of all us book bloggers, somebody committed plagiarism. No one really knew about it, until the accusers finally realized what exactly was going on. Kristi from
The Story Siren, I bet you all know her because she runs an extremely successful blog, was accused of plagiarizing from
Beautifully Invisible and
Grit and Glamour. You know how Kristi has a
Book Blog Tips and Tricks page? Well, it used to be called "Building a Better Blog," which is related to Grit and Glamour's
Build a Better Blog page. So the rest of the story was basically that Kristi was accused of plagiarizing some of the work that was posted there, and then it was supposedly settled, until this
article finally unearthed it all and we're all here today.
Check out Beautifully Invisible's
post on this, and Grit and Glamour's
post and their thoughts on plagiarism and what happened to them.
Here is what Kristi said as an apology on her site:
I owe you an explanation and an apology.
Please don’t take my silence on this issue until now as an admission to anything.
I made a mistake. I freely admit that and I am truly sorry. I am disappointed in myself and I’m embarrassed. I’m deeply saddened and distraught that I have broken your trust. While my actions were not deliberate, I don’t want to give you any excuses. In a way I feel as though it won’t matter what I say at this point. It seems that the verdict has been decided. I was accused of doing something that I am vehemently against, and intentionally or not, I know that there will be consequences.
You may be wondering why I didn’t address this issue earlier. The fact is, I thought it was taken care of privately.
After the accusations were brought to my attention I was appalled. I would never do something like that. That is NOT me. I thought that I did everything that I could do, to make the situation right.
I’ve struggled immensely with this, because this is not the type of person that I am. I felt like the fraud I was accused of being.
I didn’t want to keep it private for the reasons that you are thinking. I’m not worried about what people will think of me. I’m not saying that it doesn’t hurt, it does. I’m not immune, but that wasn’t my biggest concern. My biggest worry was the authors and publishers that I host.
I offer them something. A viewership. I offer them the chance to have their book seen. I didn’t want to deny them something that I had promised. I now fear that is the case.
I don’t expect your forgiveness. I don’t even expect you to understand. I can’t ask that you continue reading The Story Siren as a result, and I respect your decision to not do so. The only thing I ask of you is that you take this apology as a sincere one.
It's a really cryptic reply, which can be found on her site
here, but Kristi is trying to apologize for what she did. Many bloggers are saying how it's a false apology, because she's saying that she "i
ntentionally or not" did this and And, "
I didn’t want to deny them something that I had promised." That's kind of like saying that she did this because she promised something, and she didn't want to back out on that promise. I
know none of use want to back out on a promise. I get a little twitchy and uncomfortable when I have to, but I'd take having to write up a post on how sorry I am for missing something, just flat-out skipping it, or pulling an all-nighter to do write it up rather than taking the easy way out and pretty much ruining your reputation as an established book blogger.
Why Are You Angry About This?
As you can tell by my title, I want to be angry...but I really can't. I
understand. You're probably all looking at this post now with a very incredulous "Did Eileen remember to take her meds this morning?" expression. But it's true. I know that people are under stress. I know that people are driven to do things they don't want to do. I may be twelve, but I have lived with a lot of regret for my actions, and one thing that I have found out through my twelve years is that negative thoughts lead to negative actions.
So I don't want to think trash about Kristi, because I know how
awful she must feel right now, and how she is living in regret at this very second because of stress and possibly some negative thoughts. So, no, I'm not angry. But what I
can tell you I'm feeling right now is disappointment and shame. I looked up to Kristi and thought to myself, "I want my blog to be like that." Well, obviously I wanted something more
me, like a colorful background and font to reflect myself (which I hope you guys like, but don't be afraid to tell me you don't) and more book reviews and song posts, but I wanted to have dont long-term blogging like she has, to be so enthusiastic and have a love for it.
But now, I can't really say that. You might not know how I'm feeling, because you might be really mad or just neutral on the topic, but I'm disappointed that a blog that was so popular and I thought was great, wasn't actually all that. I think that Kristi should have come clean as soon as she was accused for what she did and knew it was out there. I know it sounds hard to do, and it probably is, but she really did ruin herself, and it would be better to get it out early and actually
tell people about what you did, rather than leave a cryptic message months after the accusation was made and only because somebody wrote an article on it.
I feel really bad for Kristi. You might, but I do. It might be my too-soft, young heart, or I just might be really nice, but I want to reach out and give her a hug. I really do. As I mentioned up there, Kristi might have been under lots of stress and maybe she had low self esteem at the time, thus leading to negative thoughts which always lead to negative actions. I haven't been in an exactly stressful situation, but I know what it feels like to be in a bad place, and because of maybe that one moment,
everything just collapsed. And Kristi sounds and looks like such a nice person that you honestly can't believe that she did it on a normal day, just out of the blue. I really can't.
The other thing I feel is shame. I'm a part of the book blogosphere. I sometimes prioritize my book/song blog over my own life and school, which is honestly a really bad idea and I'm trying to lessen that a tiny bit. The book blogosphere is practically my second home—I have yet to find a song blog out there, since everybody just owns YouTube channels, which I prefer much less compared to a blog.
Anyway, the point is I've grown to love the blogosphere in general and everybody in it and I feel a little ashamed to be associated with somebody who did something so horrible. I feel like
I won't be given as much credibility the next time around because of somebody else's actions. I feel like publishers will have to background check much more before they're willing to send out an ARC or review copy, which I have enough trouble to procure in the first place. So, I just want to have that sense that I'm going to be able to be trusted, even if I might be already.
Are YOU a Plagiarizer?
You probably
are asking this question, whether you know it or not. I've been taught at a very young age how wrong it is to plagiarize. Some people might not have gotten that luxury, but I know better. At least, I hope. I can tell you in confidence that the only thing I have
ever copied and pasted was either a book summary, book cover, song lyrics, song cover art, or some other picture to accompany my post, which I will try my very best to state where I got the content.
Now, thinking about it, since I have a very small and free button-making service, I use other people's pictures for the background and sometimes a little picture to go with it, but I make the rest myself and ad stuff to it. They're not my own. And after doing this whole post, I don't want to suffer the same fate and poor Kristi did and I'm taking it down. I might dabble now and then, but I'm not qualified to do it so I won't. As soon as I finish my most recent project, it's going down and that's that. That project is going to burn because I shouldn't be doing it anyway and I'm starting to get that gnawing feeling in my stomach.
I feel guilty just thinking about it, and I want to tell you what I did and you can be the judge of whether my act is punishable and whether you have a new view of me. I hope you aren't too troubled, but I can understand if you do and I just want you to know that I'm so sorry and forever guilty that I let it go on this far before realizing my mistake. However, I want you to know that I've learned from this mistake and next time, I won't be that foolish twelve-year-old girl that some people definitely give me credit for. I'm just happy it was with pictures, where most pictures nowadays are public domain, but I will try my best not to do it again.
But I can assure you,
I don't plagiarize. I really don't. I've been a good girl all my life, and I hope to stay that way. If I plagiarized anything, I would never share it. It would usually be for my own amusement, that's it, and afterwards, it would never see the light of day, probably burned. I want to assure you that from now on, I'm citing my sources, and I'm going to try my very best to stay as plagiarism free as possible. Forgive me if I slip up a few times, I'm going to have to work into it.
Should I Be Angry?
Yes, you
can be angry. Human emotions are volatile and tricky to deal with, and it is
all up to you. But, you shouldn't start trashing Kristi like it's nobody's business.
Yes, she made a mistake, but no, you have no right to trash her because of one slip up.She's a
human, just like you, and she has feelings and she made a mistake. You can be angry, you can be disappointed, and you can voice your opinions, but keep it from being mean.
And for those of you who've been discrediting book bloggers,
I'm one of them. I find offense that just because
one person slipped up, you can start forming opinions about the rest of us and assume we're all the same, that our reviews are all the same, because they aren't. Every blogger has a special quality about their writing style and their reviews that makes them stand out. I don't know if what mine is, but there are
awesome blogs out there that don't get enough recognition as it is, and now you've just discredited them further.
So, please, don't even
try to trash book bloggers, because even though I'm a halftime book blogger and halftime song blogger, I'm honestly extremely offended that people would just make assumptions left and right before even meeting the rest of us. I might not be a great book blogger that should be commended for my reviews, but there are without a doubt people who
do, and you just stuffed a sock in their mouth before they even started talking.
I've Been Plagiarized! Help!
Unfortunately, I've never been plagiarized, but
Grit and Glamour as well as
Beautifully Invisible both did posts on plagiarism and advice, if you want it. Parajunkee's View also did a
short feature on how to deal with it. If you have a problem or want to know what to do
if you find you've been plagiarized or want to check if you have, just go to those sites and they'll help you. But if you have any questions, you can email me and I'll try to be the best of help! :)
But the simplest advice I can give is to take some snapshots of the evidence (for people who have Macs, click Control > Shift > 4, and then drag your mouse around the area you want to capture) and then confront the blogger. Don't put them on public humiliation by exploiting them or leaving a nasty comment,
calmly email them, expressing your concern, and ask them to take down the content immediately. That's all I can say, but don't have a blowout or anything dramatic like that. Under any circumstances. You have to stay serious and composed in a situation like this, and although it's okay to have a freakout privately, don't go stomping through the Internet, spreading the news.
***All this information came from the articles that were linked above. I found this all by the articles, which I have supplied to you somewhere in this post. I hope this helped clear everything up!***
Other Mainly Impartial Posts to Look At:
Parajunkee's View
As I Turn the Pages
Some Definitely Biased Posts:
The Book Lantern
Laura's Book Review
***If you made a post and I didn't link it up, leave your link in the comments section and I'll check it out!***
EDIT: Kristi recently published a "Clarification" post to her blog, explaining what exactly happened. You can hear it firsthand from her, if you don't want to be reading outsider accounts on the issue. But some people aren't satisfied with it because she wrote an apology that wasn't really an apology and then passed it off as acting without really thinking. It's really up to you to decide what to think.
EDIT 2: I just found this really disturbing letter that Kristi sent to an ELEVEN-YEAR-OLD. I really can't believe that all that times I wanted to stay impartial turned into this. I'm still impartial, but I don't know what to think. Here's the comment that I wanted to leave Laura but never got to, but I left it on another post for her.
"Wow. That's an eleven-year-old. I'm twelve and now I feel really bad about myself because I thought that Kristi said it was okay to request for ARCs or review copies. I mean, I send requests only starting a few months ago and only send them every other month to a few select publishers, and I really hope that's not too much. I get that maybe that blogger could've been excessing it, but let him/her down easy, or don't even write the email if he/she wasn't pushing it too bad. Something more like "You might not have known this before, and I get that completely, but it's considered a little rude to ask for ARCs and finished copies excessively. Could you please try and avoid doing that next time?"
When I made my Story Siren post, I remained impartial because I have NEVER found ANY reason at all to hate somebody. I have NEVER hated somebody and I have NEVER believed that somebody deserved to be hated. And after reading that letter, I still can't find it in my heart to hate Kristi. I'm really saddened and so disappointed that Kristi could say that, albeit with the help of others, but I still can't hate her or lash out. Maybe it's because I've been in bad places and I have Tiger Parents who will push me to the point of breaking. Maybe it's because I've always believed that there's a reason behind somebody's actions. Or maybe it's because I'm just too young to be capable of those feelings.
But I can tell you one thing: I was at the point of tears reading that letter because I never thought that somebody could be called on like that for being a tween book blogger. I have always thought that all book bloggers out there were really nice, but sometimes we can get a little opinionated and angry, but I always thought that we were easy-going people who were a great community. Now I just don't know what to think."
EDIT 3: I'm sure that more than all of you (except the victims), I should be angry. I read an email to a blogger my age and found it personally insulting. I wanted to cry. I felt bad about myself for a long time after. But I'm not going to lash out and I'm not going to be mad. I am most definitely NOT going to hate her. Do you want to know WHY? I'm trying to be mature. I'm trying to keep the fire from fueling. I'm trying more than anything to believe that Kristi had a reason for everything because, in my comment above, I believe that there's always a reason.
So guys, I'm getting really frustrated with the angry comments. I know you want to express your opinions, and I didn't let on that I was too bothered in the comments that I left each one of the articles I found if you started lashing out, because you have a right to if you please. But, honestly, you really ARE establishing a bad reputation for the book blogger community because when somebody from YOUR OWN group messes up, instead of leaving a comment that BULLIES her, try to put things in perspective.
As I've said above, people are making assumptions about what I know is a fantastic community, that we're all frauds and we really aren't all that great. Well, YOU'RE SHOWING THEM THAT IT'S TRUE! I hoped that most of us would be professional and try to keep the lashing to a minimum and avoid letting too much sparks fly. I'm probably making a horrible example of myself, but I really am angry. I sound like a teacher, I feel like everybody won't listen to this, but it's true. I'm twelve-stinking-years-old, and I'm trying to get some of the adult bloggers to cease fire! I don't care if you want to express your opinions, I really don't. What I do care about is the fact that you guys want to continue to kick long after Kristi's been down.
I know what she did was pretty horrible, I know that letter was truly heinous, I know that I'm a little angry and really sad and disappointed in her behavior, but there's no need to keep on trying to torment Kristi. What if it were you getting all that poop that you're giving her? I tried to stay impartial for the sake of everybody else so they could form their own opinions, and I know she's guilty, for a fact, but I can't stay impartial about this. I have always been against bullying, and while you may not classify it as bullying, it is.
Now, not only am I disappointed in Kristi, I'm also disappointed in my fellow bloggers' behavior. It's one thing to call her out on her mistake and show that you disapprove. It's another thing to start lashing out and putting her down. Many people have made posts that call her out for what she did and admit they're mad and disappointed, but some have taken it to the extreme and they truly have made a mockery of the book blogging community.
PS—I'm sorry for getting all emotional like that, but it really bugs me. Usually I don't get mad, just frustrated, and I'm both right now. Both.